Washington INsider

Washington INsiderblog

Mark Schoeff Jr. looks at what's really happening on Capitol Hill - and the upshot for advisers.

Finra's fine money whets appetites of investor advocates, experts, industry representatives

Suggestions for uses range from establishing funds for harmed investors, those whose arbitration awards go unpaid or giving it to the Treasury Department

Oct 23, 2017 @ 1:47 pm

By Mark Schoeff Jr.

The $176.3 million in total fines Finra levied last year has mouths watering like a succulent burger coming off the grill. Investor advocates, members of Congress, scholars and industry representatives all want to take a bite.

In the last couple of months, Finra has been pressed regarding what it does with fine proceeds. The industry-funded broker-dealer regulator's opacity in this area was highlighted in September in an in-depth Mopedia analysis of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.

Then it was brought up by lawmakers at a Finra oversight hearing conducting by a House Financial Services subcommittee. The topic also was raised earlier this month in an event at the Heritage Foundation featuring Finra president and chief executive Robert W. Cook.

Not only is there an expanding chorus calling on Finra to better explain how it allocates its fine money, there also is a growing wish list of what it should do with its take.

In the House Financial Services subcommittee hearing, Rep. Brad Sherman, D-Calif., suggested that a chunk of the Finra fine money be returned to investors harmed by broker violations of Finra rules.

Another idea is for Finra to use the fine proceeds to ameliorate one of its most vexing problems — unpaid arbitration awards. A study by the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association showed that investors who won arbitration cases ended up being stiffed to the tune of $62 million in 2013, a quarter of the awards that year.

The fine largess looks inviting to the new PIABA president, Andrew Stoltmann.

"They could use $60 million of it to wipe out the unpaid arbitration problem," Mr. Stoltmann said.

Another group that might want to tap the fine pool for unpaid arbitration is the Financial Services Institute.

At the Heritage Foundation event, David Bellaire, FSI executive vice president and general counsel, asked Mr. Cook whether Finra had considered using fine money to pay arbitration awards when brokers go bankrupt. Mr. Cook didn't directly answer that portion of Mr. Bellaire's multiple-part question.

The host of the event, Heritage scholar David Burton, suggested that Finra consider establishing an "investor reimbursement fund" or giving some of the fine proceeds to the Treasury Department.

In his appearance at Heritage, Mr. Cook reiterated what Finra says about fine revenue in its annual report. The organization uses the money, which fluctuates from year-to-year, to finance capital projects and regulatory programs.

I have my own suggestion, which stays within those parameters. In its recent report on capital markets regulation, Treasury recommended that Finra, the Securities and Exchange Commission and other regulators "centralize reporting of individuals and firms that have been subject to adjudicated disciplinary proceedings or criminal convictions."

Why not use some of Finra's fine money to finance the integration and upgrade of Finra's BrokerCheck and the SEC's Investment Adviser Registration Depository?

As it continues its Finra 360 self-examination, it's not clear whether the regulator will change the way it allocates fine proceeds. But it is hearing the rumblings about the pool of money.

"We are not going after fines to achieve a revenue goal," Mr. Cook said at the Heritage event. "We recognize there is a perception issue. We're working with the board to think through what is the right approach to fines going forward."


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Use Mopedia' to find exclusive information and intelligence about the independent broker-dealer industry.

Rank Broker-dealers by

For many socially responsible investors, fixed income has gone largely ignored. But the opportunities are endless. Ryan Dings of SunWealth offers some ideas.

Video Spotlight

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Merrill Lynch releases new compensation plan

Advisers bringing in enough accounts will be rewarded, those falling short will see compensation cut.

Brian Block sentenced to 18 months in prison

The government had sought a sentence of at least seven years against the former Nick Schorsch colleague.

LPL says it's on track to recruit 70% of National Planning Holdings revenue

Rivals have picked off some big NPH teams, but LPL said it is getting the lion's share of revenue from the acquisition.

Philip Palaveev on how firms should be recruiting young talent

Next generation needs and deserves more attention and training.

Breakaway broker deals a drag on M&A activity in third quarter

The 29 deals in the third quarter compare with 45 and 40 deals in the first and second quarters, respectively.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

mutual fund vs annuity how to invest 401k funds index fund ratings tdf bank do employer contributions count towards hsa limit 1099 pension how to withdraw 401k early without penalty how are ssi benefits calculated tsp investment calculator cfp salary range required 401k withdrawal vanguard vs fidelity 401k merrill lynch managed accounts define imputed interest vang target ret 2035 promissory note tax implications t rowe price high yield fund fktfx financial advisor wealth management salary t rowe price retirement 2035 fund minimum irs interest rate american funds income fund of america a reit distributions vanguard roth ira calculator child ssi calculator qualified dividend tax turbotax plus fee best bond etf rising interest rates nosgx state farm mutual funds investing in international bonds cfp exam 2015 medicare costs per person turbotax federal state loomis sayles investment grade bond fund savings account rbc growth stock mutual funds 10 year track record vanguard s and p etf