Morgan Stanley's broker protocol exit: How did we get here?

As the number of signatories to the protocol has swelled over the years, so too has the gamesmanship Morgan Stanley cites as its reason for leaving, according to experts

Nov 2, 2017 @ 10:00 am

By Greg Iacurci

Morgan Stanley dropped an industry bombshell this week upon announcing it would leave the broker protocol, a 13-year-old agreement that governs how financial advisers could leave one brokerage firm for another without getting in legal trouble.

Some observers are hypothesizing this is the first of many dominos to fall, with an exodus of other big brokerage firms leading to an environment harking back to the '90s and early 2000s — one that's more contentious and litigious — when an adviser jumps ship.

How did we get to this point?

Merrill Lynch, UBS PaineWebber and Smith Barney were the founding signatories of the agreement, the Protocol for Broker Recruiting, in 2004. Morgan Stanley and Wachovia Securities (now Wells Fargo Advisors), the remaining wirehouse firms, followed in 2006.

Now, more than 1,500 firms voluntarily participate.

Prior to its establishment, big brokerage houses would seek to prevent clients (and their assets) from walking out the door by taking legal action against the departing adviser. Typically, that took the form of a temporary restraining order preventing the adviser from contacting, and soliciting, his or her clients pending a negotiation.

"The [temporary restraining order] was almost becoming commoditized," said Danny Sarch, founder and owner of Leitner Sarch Consultants, an adviser recruiting firm.

The broker protocol was the industry's answer to tamping down on litigation and issues that emerged around privacy of client data.


Mindy Diamond, president and CEO at recruiting firm Diamond Consultants, equates the agreement to a "mutual truce" — advisers who were part of signatory firms could leave without being sued if they followed certain rules, such as only taking a limited amount of client information.

The protocol's language hasn't changed over the years, but the way firms have operated within its boundaries has, straining the protocol amid allegations of gamesmanship by some participants.

"This has really cropped up over the past five or six years. It's become a lot more evident," Thomas B. Lewis, a partner at the law firm Stevens & Lee, said. Firms didn't initially use loopholes when the "large mainstream broker-dealers" were the only members, he added.

Some observers point to JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Bank of America Merrill Lynch as examples of firms gaming the rules via certain exclusions. In other words, they and other firms are partly in and partly out of the protocol, leading to circumstances where they may poach brokers at liberty but punish those trying to leave, the observers said.

"There's a lot of confusion right now with certain firms, and certain small firms that could be using the protocol to their advantage when it is advantageous, and taking the position the protocol doesn't apply in other situations," Mr. Lewis said.

JPMorgan holds that registered representatives at the firm's brokerage — a legacy of Bear Stearns, which JPMorgan acquired — are covered by the protocol, but says reps in JPMorgan's private bank aren't covered by the agreement. JPMorgan sees the protocol as pertaining only to commission-based brokers, not the employees in the private bank who receive a salary and bonus to service clients.

Similarly, Merrill Lynch distinguishes between brokers who build their books of businesses on their own, and those who use in-house referrals to do so. The former group is covered by the protocol. The firm has said brokers have a choice between the two classifications.

"They were able to have their cake and eat it too," Mr. Sarch said of the firms. He added, though, that there's logic in the dichotomy, because "but for the bank's introduction they would not know that client."

Merrill Lynch spokeswoman Susan McCabe and JPMorgan spokesman Robert Carosella declined comment.


But it's not only the big brokerage firms that have gamed the rules to a certain extent, observers said. Some small independent shops recruiting from larger firms join the protocol to make it easier to hire an adviser, but then exit the protocol shortly after hiring to make it difficult to leave.

Further, inherited accounts, or those an adviser inherits from a retiring or departing broker, also typically fall outside the protections of the rules. So, the inheriting adviser wouldn't subsequently be able to solicit those accounts upon departure from the firm.

Take a case involving Morgan Stanley and Connecticut-based brokers leaving for Janney Montgomery Scott as a recent example. Morgan Stanley sued for, and this year won, a permanent injunction against advisers Shane O'Brien and June Strunk preventing them from soliciting accounts inherited from a retiring Morgan Stanley broker.

Which all brings us back to the present. Morgan Stanley cited such so-called loopholes as a primary reason for leaving the broker protocol on Nov. 3, subsequently subjecting employees to a one-year non-solicit agreement if they leave.

But some observers don't buy it, and suspect the argument is an excuse to try to stem attrition at the firm.

"If you're a net loser of advisers, and have been for years, the protocol is just making the door out easier," Mr. Sarch said.

When asked for comment, a Morgan Stanley spokeswoman referred to the company's original announcement about the protocol departure, which says the firm will now be able to "invest more heavily in its world class advisers and their teams" to drive growth.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Use Mopedia' to filter and find key information on over 1,400 fee-only registered investment advisory firms.

Rank RIAs by

Use Mopedia' to find exclusive information and intelligence about the independent broker-dealer industry.

Rank Broker-dealers by

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join Mopedia at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Guidestone's David Spika says great data is critical for great socially responsible investing. Why and how can it work in your client's portfolio?

Video Spotlight

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Merrill Lynch releases new compensation plan

Advisers bringing in enough accounts will be rewarded, those falling short will see compensation cut.

Brian Block sentenced to 18 months in prison

The government had sought a sentence of at least seven years against the former Nick Schorsch colleague.

Clayton: SEC targets 'complex, hidden fees'

Putting clients in expensive share classes instead of lower-cost ones hurts investors, chairman says.

LPL says it's on track to recruit 70% of National Planning Holdings revenue

Rivals have picked off some big NPH teams, but LPL said it is getting the lion's share of revenue from the acquisition.

Philip Palaveev on how firms should be recruiting young talent

Next generation needs and deserves more attention and training.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

social security survival benefits cashing in life insurance policy taxable what is medicare surcharge pension lump sum calculator earning limit for social security 2014 bd jocks state farm annuity franklin income fund morningstar highest yield money market cost of h and r block tax preparation south carolina retirement system calculator contribute to sep ira and traditional ira roth ira deadlines fidelity self employed 401 k great west bond index fund i 401k ira rollover tiaa cref lifecycle retirement income fund deferred annuity calculator monthly payment alliancebernstein core opportunities fund t rowe price sign in franklin templeton debt funds pensions lump sum vs monthly payments what are reit's 1988 ferrari f40 for sale 401k fix it guide vanguard vs fidelity index funds franklin income class a neuberger berman mlp income ira penalty age vanguard retirement planner cashing in life insurance policies social security administration alexandria va hsas band