On Retirement

Lump sum or monthly pension? How I made my decision

Advisers likely to hear this question from clients more often

Aug 17, 2014 @ 12:01 am

By Mary Beth Franklin

Recently, an investor wrote to me asking if he should accept his employer's offer of a lump-sum payout in lieu of a monthly pension. Of course, such a decision depends on a person's financial needs, life expectancy and access to other assets, so I encouraged him to consult a financial adviser.

But the question struck a chord with me, as I was offered a similar choice recently. And it is an issue that in the near future is likely to start coming up more frequently in conversations with clients.

“Many plan sponsors are settling their liabilities with former employees by offering them lump-sum cash-outs,” Jim Ritchie, a principal in Mercer's retirement practice, said in a recent report about pension plans sponsored by S&P 1500 companies.

The funding status remained relatively stable, at about 85%, during the first half of 2014, according to Mr. Ritchie. Pension plans must be at least 80% funded to allow employers to offer lump-sum buyouts to vested employees.

Another compelling reason for companies to transfer liabilities and risks to employees: major increases in Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp.'s per-participant premiums. The premiums, which are paid annually, will rise by more than 30%, to $64, in 2016, from $49 in 2014. They are tied to inflation thereafter.

“A buyout eliminates paying these annual premiums, along with other administrative costs, which are often a large part of the cost in maintaining the plan,” the Mercer report stated. “The current economic environment, together with the increase in PBGC premiums and mortality update on the horizon, makes 2014 an attractive time for sponsors to consider an annuity buyout as an effective risk management tool,” it said.

GUARANTEED BENEFIT

Frankly, until the letter arrived from a former employer in June offering me a lump-sum payout, I was looking forward to a pension of about $1,700 per month that I could start collecting in five years, when I turn 65. I felt lucky to have a guaranteed retirement benefit in this post-pension era. But at the same time I was disappointed, because the amount could have been so much larger had the plan not been frozen about 10 years after I became eligible to participate.

After much deliberation and consultation with my financial adviser, I decided to take the lump sum.

Some people may be surprised by my decision, as I am such a big proponent of having sufficient guaranteed income to cover fixed costs in retirement. The combination of a pension and a smart Social Security claiming strategy can go a long way to pay for many of those recurring costs.

But selecting a lump-sum payout now will allow me to create an even bigger monthly benefit in the future.

RATE-DEPENDENT

Using the federal government's current low interest rates of 1.17% for the first five years, 4.29% for the next 15 years and 5.36% thereafter, my monthly annuity translates into a lump sum of about $207,000 today. If I wait five years until my normal retirement age of 65 to collect, the lump sum value drops to about $189,000 under current interest rate assumptions. If interest rates rise, it would require a smaller lump sum to generate the same monthly benefit.

For most clients, taking a lump sum transfers the risk of lifetime income from the employer to the employee. You must be careful in accepting that risk and determining how to invest the money to provide adequate income for life.

I was fortunate. I owned a deferred variable annuity with living benefits inside my individual retirement account and was able to roll over the entire lump sum into that investment vehicle.

The annuity guarantees a minimum rise of 6% a year — possibly better, depending on the market performance of my aggressively invested subaccounts — and the guaranteed balance resets at the highest point each year.

If the money earns the minimum guaranteed rate of 6% a year, my lump sum payout will be worth about $277,000 when I turn 65 — about a third more than it is today. If the market performs better than the guarantee, I could come out well ahead.

Of course, as several Mopedia readers have correctly pointed out, the minimum annual increase applies only to the guaranteed balance that is the basis for annuitizing the contract. If instead I want to take periodic withdraws subject to contract limits, they would be based on the actual account balance that reflects the performance of the underlying investments. In a worst case scenario, I could deplete the actual account balance, and I still have the right to annuity payouts for the rest of my life.

I know many people argue that it is ridiculous to put a tax-deferred annuity inside a tax-deferred IRA. It's the old belt-and-suspenders argument.

But frankly, when I bought the annuity during the ugly days of the market crash of 2009, I was more concerned about guarantees than tax deferral. I'm happy with my choice, and it's a guarantee that I doubt I could match today.

There likely will be a large number of pension buyouts in the near future. Be ready with appropriate answers for clients who ask for guidance about their choices.

This article has been updated to clarify that the 6% minimum annual increase applies only to the guaranteed balance that is the basis for annuitizing the contract.

(Questions about Social Security? Find the answers in my e-book, available at Mopedia.com/MBFebook.)

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Apr 30

Conference

Retirement Income Summit

Join Mopedia at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Advisers expect a lot more from their technology and that begins with a great client experience. Rich Cancro of AdvisorEngine discusses how an elegant technology platform can help an adviser to stand out to clients, prospects, and future employees.

Video Spotlight

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video

Channels

Latest news & opinion

Raymond James executives call on industry to keep broker protocol

Also ask firms to pay for the administration of the protocol to 'ensure its longevity and relevance.'

House passes tax bill, focus turns to Senate

Tax reform legislation expected to have more of a challenge in upper chamber.

SEC enforcement of advisers drops in Trump era

The agency pursued 82 cases against advisers and firms in fiscal year 2017, down from 98 the previous year.

PIABA accuses Finra of conflicts of interest

Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association report slams self-regulator over its picks for board of governors.

Betterment launches 'free' charitable-giving platform

Robo-software provider lets investors donate directly from their accounts, and will not charge charities with less than $1 million on the platform.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

pension annuity lump sum cash out life insurance taxable charles schwab fee investing for retirement calculator turbotax premier 2014 vanguard intermediate term investment grade fund fidelity spartan emerging markets index fund fidelity capital income turbo tax state and federal life insurance vs 401k swan defined risk strategy prudential retirement ups vanguard target retirement 2035 trp retirement 2020 fidelity otc mutual fund how do you determine what tax bracket you re in metlife total control account customer service can you rollover a 401k to an ira naic suitability in annuity transactions model regulation cost of h and r block tax preparation no lapse guarantee universal life insurance morningstar etf managed portfolios landscape report virtus multi sector fixed income fund do you pay tax on life insurance payout brown capital management small company fund how much is a 1945 copper penny worth franklin templeton money fund social security benefits for children of deceased parent intra family loan agreement template h&r block fees for tax preparation distribution code 7 on form 1099 r 1943 steel penny for sale schwab sign up bonus eaton vance high yield pokemon charizard first edition technology stocks to watch 401k loan hardship rules where is the adjusted gross income on w2 fidelity freedom fund 2050