When clients call the stock market a big bubble, here's what to say

But talk of bubbles doesn't mean the same thing as expensive or overvalued, and bubbles are rare and hard to predict

Aug 19, 2016 @ 11:20 am

By John Waggoner

The next time a client tells you that stocks are in a bubble, consider a polite way to say, “I don't think that word means what you think it means.”

Earlier this month, Republican presidential nomineee Donald Trump declared that the stock market is “all a big bubble.” CNBC ran a headline in June: “Uh oh. Is the stock market a bubble again?” And former Office of Management and Budget head David Stockman warned Friday, “The Implosion is Near: Signs of the Bubble's Last Days.”

But “bubble” doesn't mean the same thing as “expensive” or “overvalued.” Jeremy Siegel, Russell E. Palmer Professor of Finance at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia, said the term is overused.

“It used to be reserved for something way, way overvalued. Now anyone who thinks a market is overvalued says it's a bubble,” Mr. Siegel said.

Few would argue that stocks are cheap. Currently, the Standard & Poor's 500 stock index sells for 18.1 times earnings, which is a premium to its historical norm. Even that may not be terribly overvalued, given the current level of interest rates. (More on that in a moment.) During the technology bubble, however, the S&P 500 was selling for more than 30 times earnings, and many of the technology darlings of the day had no earnings whatsoever.

“A good rule of thumb is that something should be 100% or 200% above its fundamental value before it's a bubble,” Mr. Siegel said

One of the hallmarks of a bubble is that it's most easily detected after it has popped. Part of this is because there's a certain logic to high prices at the time. Technology in general and the internet in particular were, in fact, altering the fabric of life and business in ways that were hard to imagine in the 1990s. It's just that only a handful of those pioneering companies would live up to expectations and valuations. For every Amazon, there was a Pets.com.

And this is not just true for the tech wreck, and it's not just dummies who get caught up in them. Isaac Newton went broke chasing the South Seas bubble, which centered around a British company granted a monopoly on trade in the Pacific. George Washington invested in the Patowmack Canal, part of the canal mania that seized the nation in the early 19th century. It was a failure.

Naturally, there's a cachet to having predicted a bubble. You'd be surprised at how many people say they predicted the housing bust or the tech wreck. You'd probably be surprised at how few did so successfully. If you predicted a bubble five years before it burst, you were simply wrong.

Bubbles normally move so powerfully beyond what skeptics expect that many of those who bet against it go bust before the bubble does. Alan Greenspan said that “irrational exuberance” was prevalent in stocks on Dec. 5, 1996, when the Dow Jones Industrial Average stood at 744.38. It nearly doubled, to 1401.69, by the market peak on March 9, 2000. A bet against tech in 1996 would have bankrupted you long before the bubble burst.

Bubbles are usually rare, although we've seen two burst in the U.S. in the past 15 years — one in technology and one in housing. (One might be tempted to add in the Chinese A share market to the list of global bubbles). Serious bubble-watchers should probably keep an eye on the bond market. Charles Poor Kindleberger, author of Manias, Panics and Crashes, the definitive work on bubbles, noted that bubbles nearly invariably depend on the growth of credit. “Most expansions of money and credit do not lead to a mania; there are many more economic expansions than there are manias,” he wrote. “But every mania has been associated with the expansion of credit.”

Low bond yields in the U.S. are a bubble, One hallmark of a bubble is euphoria, and you probably haven't gotten bond tips from a shoeshine boy recently. But negative interest rates in Europe are unprecedented, and one cause of low rates in the U.S. In July, Swiss 50-year bond yields turned negative. Barring economic conditions similar to the 100 Years War, it's hard to imagine turning a profit on those bonds if held to maturity.

What do you say when your client tells you that stocks are in a bubble? Tell them that stocks are expensive, that it will take an increase in earnings or a modest decline in prices to get them back to normal — and that they shouldn't invest unless they have a long-term outlook. What do you say if they think bonds might be in a bubble? That's a harder conversation.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join Mopedia at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

We are at the "knee in the curve" of a transformation of the financial advice industry, according to Ric Edelman. But what's next and how will it shape your practice of the future?

Video Spotlight

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Broker, retirement groups make last-minute pleas to change tax legislation

Pass-through provisions are target of groups representing employee-model brokerage firms, as well as retirement plan advisers.

House and Senate reach tentative compromise for tax overhaul

Lawmakers still need to get a cost analysis of their agreement, so it's not yet definite, according to a source.

Advisers' biggest fears for 2018

What keeps advisers up at night.

John W. Brower, president and CEO of JW Brower & Associates, shares the story behind his son's death from a heroin overdose and how it inspired him to help others break the cycle of addiction.

Tax reform will boost food, chemicals, rail stocks. Technology? Not so much

Conagra and Berkshire Hathaway are two stocks that should benefit most from changes in the tax code.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

vanguard s&p index fund vanguard high yield tax exempt sep ira contribution deadline how to collect spousal social security benefits spousal social security benefits for divorced spouses sei core fund turbotax 2014 deal roll over ira to roth social security paper checks h&r block tax preparation cost how do i apply for survivor benefits social security ssa 1099 form annuity vs lump sum calculator eafe stock index fund vanguard new york long term tax exempt fund merrill lynch wealth management fee schedule john hancock long term care claims what is a 1099-r form used for how much is a charizard first edition worth social security act of 1935 purpose commonwealth annuity and life insurance company ratings oppenheimer main street fund class a van eck global hard assets fund government pension offset and windfall elimination provision t rowe price health sciences portfolio what is the spousal benefit for social security john hancock customer service phone number conversion from traditional to roth ira rules certified financial planner designation craigslist rockville md jobs janus global life sciences fund d matthews china dividend fund lord abbett growth and income why was the social security act of 1935 created eaton vance atlanta capital smid-cap i is s&p 500 a good investment ex spouse survivor benefits