Finra: Morgan Stanley must pay Schwab $1.2 million over broker recruiting violation

Arbitrators rule that Morgan Stanley violated trade secrets by "maliciously and willfully" appropriating a Schwab client list

Nov 3, 2017 @ 5:24 pm

By Mark Schoeff Jr.

A Finra arbitration panel awarded $1.2 million to Charles Schwab & Co. Inc. in a case against Morgan Stanley Smith Barney involving the recruitment of a Schwab broker.

In a Nov. 2 award, the arbitrators found that Morgan Stanley violated the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act by diverting Schwab clients of a broker called "Mr. Q." The broker's customer list, which included contact and financial information, were deemed trade secrets.

"MSSB misappropriated [Schwab's] trade secrets during the recruitment, hiring and employment of Mr. Q., and did so maliciously and willfully," the award states.

Schwab claimed that Morgan Stanley "orchestrated the departure and wrongful actions of Mr. Q, [Schwab's] former employee, by inducing Mr. Q" to take his customer list and clients to Morgan Stanley.

The arbitrators said that Schwab did not sign and was not bound by the protocol for broker recruiting. The case was filed in March 2016. Morgan Stanley announced this week that it is withdrawing from the protocol.

Morgan Stanley did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The firm's penalty breaks down as $360,000 in compensatory damages, $289,524 in attorneys' fees and $600,000 in punitive damages.

"We're pleased with Finra's decision in this matter," said Schwab spokesman Rob Farmer. "We take these issues related to confidentiality, client solicitation and intellectual property very seriously. We intend to pursue breaches when they occur through appropriate legal action."

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Guidestone's David Spika says great data is critical for great socially responsible investing. Why and how can it work in your client's portfolio?

Video Spotlight

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video

Channels

Latest news & opinion

LPL cuts fees for advisers using its corporate RIA platform

The independent broker-dealer is increasing reimbursement fees for advisers using its strategic asset management platform, or SAM.

Ed Slott on Roth IRA conversions becoming permanent

Proposal would remove recharacterization option from advisers' toolkit.

Tax reform: How the House bill changes rules for retirement savings

While pre-tax 401(k) contribution limits are off the table (for now), the Republican tax bill nonetheless makes changes to retirement savings plans.

SEC Chairman Jay Clayton's quest to forge a fiduciary standard

The new SEC chairman is confident he can up come with a rule better than that of the Department of Labor — one that satisfies brokers, investment advisers and investor advocates alike.

Morgan Stanley advisers feel burned by broker protocol exit

Some reps, including those already thinking of leaving, say the firm only cares about the bottom line.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

how to calculate social security benefits formula t rowe price international growth and income fund direct ira rollover merrill lynch managed accounts medicare modified adjusted gross income turbotax software refund social security and divorced spouses ssa-1099 social security benefit statement us dollar bear etf minimum 401k withdrawal rules franklin templeton growth fund class a turbo tax low income t rowe price high yield muni vanguard international small cap fagix dividend roth conversion irs how to calculate pension lump sum red oak commodity advisors investment grade spreads ready assets prime money fund conseco direct life insurance company blackrock emerging markets allocation fund renting a house tax implications early withdrawal of 401k without penalty dow jones industrial definition private benjamin torrent 401a early withdrawal american funds insurance series growth fund john hancock small cap index fund t rowe price new era lump sum payment vs monthly pension is fica the same as social security allstate lawsuit military roth tsp