Fidelity pushes Vanguard to compete on brand in 401(k) plans

With Fidelity imposing an additional fee, Vanguard likely will look less attractive compared with comparably priced index-fund providers, advisers said

Jan 24, 2018 @ 2:48 pm

By Greg Iacurci

Fidelity Investments' move to impose an additional fee on Vanguard Group assets is going to test plan sponsors' loyalty to the index-fund giant, according to retirement plan advisers, as employers are forced to choose between sticking with a trusted low-cost brand and paying less money for a similar investment product from a different provider.

Advisers and other observers believe Vanguard's brand power won't be enough to overcome the extra cost in many instances.

"Will this deter flows into Vanguard funds in Fidelity plans? The answer is 100%, exclusively yes. Tremendously," said Richard J. Cawthorne Jr., president of Alpha Pension Group Inc., an advisory firm overseeing roughly $2 billion in defined-contribution-plan assets.

"The fact of the matter is we've commoditized index funds," he added. "Why pay anything extra for the same thing?"

Fidelity is the largest retirement-plan record keeper, administering more than $1.6 trillion in assets, or roughly 23% of the overall DC market. On Monday, Mopediareported that the firm will begin charging employers a 0.05% fee on all assets held in Vanguard funds. The fee applies to smaller plans — those with less than $20 million in assets.

Vanguard, the largest money manager in the DC market, is a retirement-plan titan in its own right. It manages more than $900 billion and enjoys a coveted spot as the largest manager of target-date mutual funds, which have skyrocketed to popularity in 401(k) plans.

More than 45% of 401(k) plans use a Vanguard fund, according to BrightScope Inc., which tracks a database of more than 53,000 plans. The most popular is the Vanguard Institutional Index fund, with more than $107 billion in 401(k) assets.

Observers say the 0.05% asset-based fee is the first of its kind among record keepers, and could amount to several thousand extra dollars each year for employers, depending on the size of their retirement plan.

Vanguard is in retirement plan advisers' top tier of preferred asset managers for several different 401(k) asset classes, according to Sway Research, which studies asset-management distribution. In 2016, it was the No. 1 preferred manager of target-date funds, and No. 2 in U.S. equity, U.S. fixed income, and emerging-market stocks and bonds.

"The question is, how many intermediaries and plan sponsors are loyal to Vanguard?" asked Edmund F. Murphy III, president of Empower Retirement, one of the largest DC-plan record keepers.

All things being equal — fund metrics such as fees, performance and risk-adjusted return — plan sponsors and advisers could look to different providers to offer index products, he said.

"I just couldn't imagine it wouldn't have some impact, assuming an apples-to-apples comparison," Mr. Murphy said.

Advisers point to other popular index providers that sponsors could turn to instead of Vanguard to offer a comparable product for a similar price.

Fidelity, for example, recently launched a share class of index target-date mutual fund with an average asset-weighted expense ratio of 0.12%, which is 1 basis point cheaper than Vanguard's mutual funds, making it the cheapest TDF option, according to Morningstar Inc.'s 2017 TDF report.

Charles Schwab also launched an index TDF suite in 2016 with an average asset-weighted expense ratio of 0.13%, on par with Vanguard's, according to Morningstar. The company has since reduced its pricing to 0.08%.

"I think it causes all of us to think about things differently," David Hinderstein, president of advisory firm Strategic Retirement Group Inc., said of the Fidelity fee.

"Does that cause a plan committee to take out a Vanguard fund and replace a passive index fund with a Fidelity product, which are priced very similarly?" Hinderstein asked. He said that could be a likely outcome.

Fidelity decided to impose the 0.05% fee on employers because Vanguard is the only fund company that doesn't pay fees for the administration and distribution of its funds, which it says amounts to tens of millions of dollars for Fidelity every year.

Vanguard spokeswoman Laura Edling said the fee is at odds with the progress on costs the industry has made over the past two decades. Vanguard expects employers to continue using its funds nonetheless, she said.

"This news notwithstanding, we certainly expect that sponsors and participants will continue to embrace our low-cost, broadly diversified funds as the vehicle of choice for hard-earned retirement savings," Ms. Edling said.

Jason Chepenik, managing partner at Chepenik Financial, doesn't believe Vanguard will be affected too much by the additional fee, but said other record keepers could follow Fidelity's lead.

"I think there are other companies whose eyes are opening up," he said. "Other record keepers will now look at their own model."


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Use Mopedia' to filter and find key information on over 1,400 fee-only registered investment advisory firms.

Rank RIAs by

Upcoming Event

Mar 13



Mopedia is honoring female financial advisers and industry executives who are distinguished leaders at their firms. These women have advanced the business of providing advice through their passion, creativity, inclusive approach and... Learn more

All of the noise in the District of Columbia is distracting your clients. Ben Phillips of Event Shares explains what deserves your attention (and what doesn't) as we head into 2018.

Recommended Video


Latest news & opinion

Independent broker-dealers are stepping up their game on recruiting from the wirehouses

Independent broker-dealers have narrowed the gap between themselves and the wirehouses and are able to attract more quality brokers from the Big Four.

Capital Group, sponsor of American Funds, wins 401(k) lawsuit

Decision comes as financial services companies, especially those focused on active management, have been sued for self-dealing.

SEC considers barring aggrieved investors from suing companies

Swept up by pro-business zeitgeist, regulator seeks to reverse two-decade slump in U.S. stock listings.

Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley use contrary tactics to keep advisers

Wells is helping brokers transition to independence within the firm, while Morgan is taking them to court.

Goldman's measure of risk appetite hits record

Global stocks and U.S. Treasuries are seeing their most "extreme" start to a year ever, bank says.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at Mopedia. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Last News

financial planning for widows overpaid social security tax fidelity 401k index funds mandatory 401k distributions who owns turbo tax phoenix life insurance company boston ma ira 1099 form is cash value of life insurance taxable dreyfus intermediate municipal bond fund mainstay high yield opportunities fund maine college savings program american funds investment company of america 401k rollover to roth ira rules vanguard prime money market fund fact sheet invest in real estate with ira can you roll a 401k into a simple ira social security cost of living adjustment john hancock life insurance long term care national institute of certified college planners ing usa annuity and life insurance company wells fargo third party authorization form social security for married couples maximum valuable 5 cent coins large cap growth jennison fund turbotax free state filing social security deceased spouse benefits great west bond index fund i john hancock small cap index fund charles schwab managed portfolio first command financial planning salary top asset managers by aum dimensional fund advisors reviews powershares wilderhill clean energy